Saturday, June 28: Mississippi Mud
GROUP THERAPY
by John M. Floyd
One of the things I remember from “Jurassic Park” was Sam Neill watching the dinosaurs from a distance and saying, “They do move in herds.” Well, so do we. Not many of us humans enjoy being alone too often — it’s more fun to band together. Especially with others who share the same interests.
Take writers, for example. Dreaming up stories and putting them on paper is a lonely task, and it makes sense that writers enjoy clumping together now and then and sharing ideas and experiences. Readers do too, for that matter. Readers’ groups, usually called “book clubs” instead, are probably at least as numerous as writers’ groups — and I’ve attended some of both, over the past few years.
I’m currently a member of the Southern Writers’ Group, which meets twice a month at a local library. Not a very original name, but it’s appropriate: we’re Southern, we’re writers, and we’re a group. As for my being a member, I’m actually more of an attendee. We don’t have members as such because we’re not that organized: we have no officers, no dues, etc. We like it that way. We’re just a bunch of friends who happen to be writers, or writers who happen to be friends. But we’ve been meeting for a long time now, so I guess we’re doing something right.
The odd thing is, we’re a writers’ group but not a “critique group.” Attendees are free to bring samples of their writing, either finished or in progress, and read them to the others in the group, but it’s not a requirement, and doesn’t even happen that often. Mostly we just get together and talk about anything involving writing and/or publishing, and share news and market info and success (or failure) stories. I guess we’re more of a “support group,” as if we all suffer from the same disease. Which, in a way, we do.
The group includes both published and unpublished writers, and folks who do almost every kind of writing: essays, novels, columns, children’s books, poems, screenplays, textbooks, articles, devotionals, memoirs, cookbooks, short stories, songs, how-to books, etc. One of the good things about our meetings is that I usually learn more about not only my area of expertise but others’ as well.
The readers’ group that I attend once a month (actually about four or five times a year is more like it, for me) is fun also, because it focuses on mysteries. It’ll probably come as no surprise to anyone that most of the attendees of this group are ladies, because — let’s face it — most readers are ladies. And they’re truly mystery buffs. I had thought I read a lot of mystery/suspense until I met these folks, some of whom read a couple of books a week. Years ago we had a “leader” who read a dozen or so mysteries each month (I’m serious, a dozen), made detailed notes, and gave us synopses of these books so we could decide whether to read them ourselves. Lately the leader is more of a facilitator, and has each attendee tell the others about whatever mysteries he or she happened to read recently. The end result is the same: we all learn more about what’s available and — most importantly — what’s good and what’s not.
It’s also a great place to find out about new authors. I was introduced there to the novels of Marcus Sakey, Harlan Coben, Janet Evanovich, Robert Crais, and many others. (Coben, Evanovich, and Crais have been around awhile now, but if you’ve not heard of Sakey, I encourage you to give him a try. He’s written only two novels, The Blade Itself and At the City’s Edge, but both are excellent.)
My point is, if you’re a writer or a reader — and I know some of you are both — consider joining an existing group, or organizing one yourself. Believe me, the hours you spend in the company of those who share your love for reading and/or writing is time well spent. I look forward to every meeting, and always leave feeling more knowledgeable and more inspired.
Let me ask you something. Do you ever attend a readers’ or writers’ group? If not, why? Would you, if one was available? If you do attend, what kind of group is it? Critique? Discussion? How often do you meet? Do you find it worthwhile?
I’ll close with this picture: Imagine several of your non-reader friends, sitting on a distant hilltop, watching a group of intense-looking writers or readers filing into a meeting room. One of the observers lowers his binoculars and turns to the others with an intrigued look on his face and says, “They do move in herds.”
The library a mere three blocks away hosts regular meetings for writers and another for readers. I have never attended a meeting of either group.
Why? I’m not sure. After reading your column I might give it a try.
I meet weekly with two different critique groups and we also discuss what we have been reading. And I do think it is worthwhile. The feed back is good as is the deadline to have something to bring each week.
I’m not sure I find writing as solitary as a lot of people say it is. I become quite interested in my fictional characters, … Perhaps I’m just a misanthrope. Like P.G Wodehouse, there are times when “I never want to see anyone, and I never want to go anywhere or do anything, I just want to write.”
I recently ended up in charge of a small, local writers’ group that has evolved to include written and oral critiques, internal networking and a twice-yearly writers’ retreat in rural settings where we get up to 3 days to do nothing but write and socialize with fellow writers. We meet twice a month in a conference room of the local public library and critique each others work and discuss the markets and what’s happening out there. When no one has anything “on the table” for critique, we still meet and read through handouts on various aspects of the art and business of writing.
Do I find attending a writing group worthwhile? You bet I do. After eight years it is still painful as hell to submit a story to these people and have it ripped apart … but I’ve become a much better writer by being shown my mistakes and seeing how other writers handle the same problems. It’s tough on the ego to have six people in a row say “I didn’t understand this”, but it’s far better to figure out now that it doesn’t work, rather than to have it make the rounds and gather rejection slips by the bushel and you not know why.
If you write but don’t belong to a writer’s group, you ought to. And if you can’t find one in your area, consider starting one at the local public library–that’s how MY group got its start.
I think it’s interesting how certain things work well for some writers and not for others. I know folks who really thrive when given deadlines and some who must work only at their own pace, some who love to read their work aloud and others who hate it, some who readily accept criticism and some who want only to be patted on the head and told everything’s great.
Personally, I think I’m one of those who just need to talk regularly to other writers about the business and process of writing/publishing, from marketing to work habits to style issues and so on. I usually learn a lot from that, and that part of a writing group is fun for me. I also like hearing about other writers’ successes and publications.
The ONE thing I don’t usually talk to others about is my own work in progress. Okay, I know that’s odd (especially since I enjoy hearing my fellow writers read from their own stories), but I think telling someone else — anyone else — the essentials of a storyline I’m working on tends to make me less interested in that storyline. And if I did it enough times I probably would wind up not writing it at all. Just one of my many quirks.
I should never have brought those handcuffs.