Monday, June 16: The Scribbler
PLEDGE DRIVE
by James Lincoln Warren
About a week and a half ago, Rob wrote about reading tie-in books related to television series. An auspicious topic, for without the advent of the tie-in novel1, a great organization would never have come into being. You might think that I am referring to the International Association of Media Tie-In Writers, or IAMTW (“I AM a Tie-in Writer!” their website proudly proclaims), founded three years ago by Lee Goldberg and Max Allan Collins, but you’d be wrong, or at most, obliquely correct. No, my friends, I am not talking about IAMTW, but a far more inclusive (by which I mean non-discriminatory, in the sense that we lack any sense of discrimination whatsoever) organization, the Professional Hack Authors RecogniTion Society, or PHARTS, phounded by James Lincoln Warren and Paul Guyot.
How did the tie-in novel bring about such a gathering of great wordsmithy? Glad you asked.
When Lee originally announced the formation of IAMTW, a lot of folks out there thought it was a joke. They reasoned that the entire concept of an organization devoted to writers who take on such projects purely for the paycheck only could not possibly be serious. But they were wrong. Lee made the claim that he always brought his best game to tie-in projects, and that he wrote as seriously for them as for his “original” fiction. He thought that tie-in writers were not getting any respect, that THEY, and not nonfiction writers as John has suggested, are the true Rodney Dangerfields of the writing community. IAMTW was created to counter that perception. 2 But by demanding respect, Lee and Al had obviously left a serious void in the ranks of writers organizations.
So Guyot and I rushed in where angels fear to tread, to provide an organization that truly was a joke, but which was also dedicated to getting the check. PHARTS was born, the first writers group for dedicated hacks.3 (How about our nifty new seal, folks? Guyot and I worked very hard to get it right. We think it’s TWICE the seal of those IAMTW dudes and dudettes.)
I quote from our home page: “The Professional Hack Authors RecogniTion Society, or PHARTS, is an organization for professional hack authors, i.e., mercenary wordsmiths who don’t care a fig for style, content, originality, or grammar, but are willing to write anything for money. We are of all ages, races, ethnic backgrounds, religious persuasions, and sexual preferences, comprising even Old PHARTS, New PHARTS, Red PHARTS, Blue PHARTS.”
The PHARTS website includes the Hack Writers Library, “Featuring all the Professional Self-Help Authoring Tools You Will Ever Need!” 4 But if there is one lesson that PHARTS can teach the aspiring writer, that lesson is the value of plagiarism. Because ideas are best if they are swiped from somewhere else, since it requires much less work to rip off than it does to think, we at PHARTS steal whatever good ideas we find. And one of those ideas is the Public Broadcasting Pledge Drive, one of the most insidious and irritating cultural phenomena ever to inflict itself on an unsuspecting public.
Yes, that’s right, PHARTS is having our second ever Pledge Drive. 5 We can call it a Pledge Drive instead just a Membership Drive because of the way that PHARTS handles its dues. PHARTS dues are pledged, not paid! That’s right! All you have to do to join PHARTS is fill in a few questions and send us an IOU! The kicker is that in order to quit, you have to pay off your marker. So PHARTS membership is for life, kind of like prison after commiting a heinous crime! Isn’t that great? We think so.
But what kind of Pledge Drive would it be if we didn’t have a Special Offer if You Join in the Next Fifteen Minutes? You already get a neat-o PDF Certificate when you join, so what could be better? Well, if You Join in the Next Fifteen Minutes 6, PHARTS will DOUBLE YOUR ORDER and give you TWO PDF Certificates for the Price of One! That’s right!!!
Finally, I will buy a drink at the bar for any PHARTS member who attends Bouchercon 2008: Charmed to Death. Watch this space to get news of a Criminal Brief panel at the convention. 7
So what are you waiting for? Operators aren’t standing by, but what the hell. That’s what the internet is for. Apply today!8
- I just thought that I would point out that there have been short story tie-ins as well: science fiction legend James Blish wrote eleven Star Trek tie-in collections of short stories. [↩]
- It must be emphasized that writing tie-in novels should only be attempted trained professionals. When tried by by amateurs, the tragic result is fanfic, i.e., exactly the same thing done for love not money, but unsanctioned by copyright holders. [↩]
- As defined by the Oxford English Dictionary, a hack is “A person whose services may be hired for any kind of work required of him; a common drudge, … esp. a literary drudge, who hires himself out to do any and every kind of literary work; hence, a poor writer, a mere scribbler.” [↩]
- Including The Hack Writers Guide to Writing the Screenplay, by our own “Debora Helliot-Upton Sinclair”, a pseudonym. [↩]
- The first Pledge Drive was three years ago, when we phounded the organization. Since then we’ve kind of let things slide, which just goes to show what a great organization PHARTS is, since it doesn’t require you to do squat. [↩]
- These are the same Next Fifteen Minutes you must order within to get those special Two-for-One Deals advertised by Billy May on TV. [↩]
- To be moderated by Linda Landrigan, editor of Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, the panel will feature Melodie Johnson Howe, Angela Zeman, John M. Floyd, and James Lincoln Warren. Stay tuned. [↩]
- I just threw in this last footnote to see if anybody actually reads these teensy-weensy footnotes. [↩]
Excuse me.
I had nothing to do with phounding this club. To paraphrase Groucho, I’d never phind a club that would have me as a member.
I think it’s disgusting, and an insult, and a complete joke in every sense.
Speaking of cents, if there’s a job in it, I’m in!
Being already pledged and through the hazing (please tell me it’s over!), I challenge the rest of you to join PHARTS. To borrow Kinky Friedman’s campaign motto: Why the hell not?
What if I’m already an old phart?
I love Kinky though.
Glad you got your computer back.
What if I’m already an old phart?
But do you have an Official Certificate to prove it?
Elaine Flinn, Bill Crider, Barbara J. Brown, Marcia Talley, Jeraldine D. Crayne, Chester D. Campbell, Cindy Daniel, David Terrenoire, Tribe, and Dick Stodghill all do.
I have been made aware of a rumor that Lee Goldberg was offended by this post. I don’t know if this is true, but if it is, I’m very surprised, because when PHARTS was first conceived, I told Lee about it and he laughed and told me he was not insulted, and later even mentioned PHARTS on his blog.
When I announced the formation of PHARTS on the Mystery Writers of America listserv, I did so thinking I had Lee’s blessing (posted August 12, 2005):
Inspired by Lee Goldberg’s and Max Allen Collins’ recent announcement of the International Association of Media Tie-in Writers, but concerned that their new organization is a little restrictive, requiring as it does that members actually have published professional media tie-ins, Paul Guyot and I are proud to announce we have formed our own new organization, the Professional Hack Authors RecogniTion Society.
Lee has given us his blessing. Thanks, dude!
Well, in case there are any bad feelings anywhere, let me address some things and clear the air a little:
(1) PHARTS is a parody, a joke. It is not just a parody of IAMTW, although IAMTW’s formation inspired its genesis, but of every narrowly defined writers organization that ever existed, including my beloved MWA. PHARTS exists solely to make people laugh or at least smile. It was never intended to degrade and insult anyone, only to affectionately tease writers in all walks of life.
(2) In my experience, tie-in writers are consummate professionals. Yes, it is true that tie-ins are strictly commercial, but as Dr. Johnson said, “No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money.” Writing tie-in novels enables very fine writers to pay their rents and enables them to write what they want. As far as day jobs go, being a tie-in writer is probably the sweetest deal in town, because you’re doing what you love—and I do not doubt Lee and his colleagues when they say that their tie-in work is written with the same dedication to excellence as their original fiction. I would expect nothing less of someone with Lee’s tremendous talent and unimpeachable integrity. About the same time that IAMTW was getting off the ground, Lee’s wonderful stand alone novel The Man With the Iron-On Badge was published. I am not alone in saying it was one of the best crime fiction books of 2005, and also let me observe that if Lee didn’t have his television and tie-in work to support him, we would have been deprived of this wonderful book, too.
(3) True, I was deliberately tweaking Lee’s nose when implying there was no substantive difference between tie-in writing and fanfic except for mercenary motives, but I did so in jest, because I know how passionately he objects to fanfic and couldn’t resist the tease. For the record, let me state that anybody who has waded through the often obscene, disturbingly fanatical, and nearly always functionally illiterate reams of fanfic and “slash” fiction available on the internet knows that fanfic is not remotely the same thing as tie-in writing. If the issue of quality isn’t enough, there’s also honesty: tie-in writing is the legitimate extension of an entertainment franchise, there also being the as yet legally unresolved matter of fanfic’s infringement on intellectual property rights.
So there you have it. I hope any ill will has been dispersed, and I encourage anybody interested in this crazy business of writing, no matter what writing you do, to pay close attention to Lee’s blog, A Writer’s Life, one of the top ten blogs on the internet for writers and others interested in good story telling.
I’d like to contribute a Hack Writing Guide, but I don’t know how to contact the person in charge. How can I reach someone? (Feel free to reply to my e-mail address.) Thank you.
It made me laugh and smile (and yeah, pass gas!) And on my recent vacation I saw the new Indiana Jones movie, and then at the local store I bummed through the novelization. It fit in pretty well. And as I am nearing 50, call me a middle-aged-PHART. (I wrote a crappy “Time Tunnel” parody story in 9th grade, and cited William Johnson as my favorite author, so I figure I qualify in honorarium!)